|About Speeches Prior to 1850 Speeches 1850 to 1861 Civil War Era Speeches Reconstruction Era Speeches Articles|
the Tax Bill
Mr. Stevens. We are now about to take final action on this important bill. If it should become a law, it will undoubtedly be a subject of comment among well-meaning people, and be used as an engine of mischief by unprincipled men, who prefer the possession of power to the prosperity of their country. These remarks are not suggested by the conduct of any the members of this House. I take pleasure in saying that in the Committee of Ways and Means there was the entire absence of all party feeling, and the most cordial desire of every member to promote the public welfare. And I have a strong hope that the same spirit in this House will give this measure a unanimous vote; and that no member will shrink from his share of the responsibility. But while such is the patriotic spirit of this body, I cannot be blind to the use which will hereafter be made of it by small politicians. I will therefore say a few words in its defense.
The first question which will suggest itself to every citizen will be, was it necessary? For, if unnecessary, it is wholly indefensible. I will assume that every loyal man admits the necessity of everything required to extinguish this wicked rebellion. To do that, requires armies and navies. To sustain them money is absolutely necessary; for the soldiers of the Republic must not go unpaid, whatever it may cost the civilian. Money can be had only through loans; but loans cannot be had unless, at the same time, means be provided for paying punctually the interest. This nation must never repudiate her debts. This brings us to the direct question, how much must be annually raised to pay such interest? If the war were to end now or within sixty days, we could tell very nearly. I suppose our debt on the 1st day of July next will not be less than $800,000,000. When, some time since, I had occasion to address the House on the Treasury note bill, I stated our daily expenses at $2,000,000. They are now, and have been for some time past, over $3,000,000 a day. It is plain, therefore, that the sum I have stated will be rather below than above our indebtedness at the end of this fiscal year. The interest, at 7.20, will require about sixty millions of dollars annually. How much this will be increased by the necessary sacrifice of our bonds, owing the unfortunate specie clause in our Treasury note bill, it is hard to conjecture. The ordinary peace expenses of Government will not be less than $70,000,000 plus $60,000,000; these together will be $130,000,000, independent of the increase in our pension list. My learned colleague from Vermont (Justin Morrill) estimates the revenue from this bill and from customs at $163,000,000. We have been so little accustomed to national taxation, that our statistics and means of ascertaining the actual product of this bill are very scanty. Any estimates must necessarily be very imperfect. Much will depend on the amount of trade and the prosperity of domestic industry.
I am fearful that my colleagues has over-estimated the amount for the first year. But for the second year, when stock on hand which will escape this tax shall have been consumed. I believe the amount will go considerably above his estimate. But as the amount of interest for the first year will be considerably less than the second year, I have a confident hope that this bill, with other revenue, will raise at least $15,000,000 beyond the interest and ordinary expenses of Government. If our debt should not be increased beyond $1,200,000,000, and commerce should revive, I believe, in after years, we shall have a surplus of $50,000,000 to apply to the reduction of the debt. This calculation is merely hypothetical, as I cannot foresee the course of the Government in dealing with the rebellion. If they should use the legitimate means in their power, I have no doubt that in ninety days the rebels would be so crippled that our army could safely be reduced to one hundred thousand men, and five sixth of the present expenses be saved. In that case I feel no hesitancy in predicting that not another dollar in taxes need ever be imposed on the people to defray our whole debt. If the Government should further determine, in accordance with the practice of nations, the dictates of wisdom and of justice, to make the property of the rebels pay the expenses of the war which they have so wantonly caused, this tax need never be collected beyond the second year.
But if the Administration should deem it wise to prolong the war, and suffer the loyal citizens to be oppressed, to show mercy to the traitors, the people must expect further and heavier burdens. In selecting the objects of taxation, the committee have found it necessary to visit many articles which they would have gladly spared. They have, however, laid no burdens on those who have but small means. They have exempted property and business below the value of $600, so that the poor manís tenement shall not be disturbed by the tax gatherer. For the same reason they have laid no poll tax. They have, no doubt, notwithstanding their best efforts, failed to equalize the burden to the extent which they desired. They have attempted to raise the largest sums from articles of luxury, and from the large profits of wealthy men. But even on these articles the tax is light compared with that of other countries. Take spirits as a sample. You may call it a luxury or a nuisance, as best suits your taste. The excise in England is $2.50 per gallon; here 15 cents. Tobacco stands the same list. Even now, when England has reduced her tariff, her duty on raw material is seventy-two cents per pound; on manufactured, or cigars, $2.16; on snuff, $1.44; on stems and straps, seventy-two cents. In this bill, the raw material is free; manufactured, ten cents per pound; cigars, ten cents; smoking, five cents; snuff, many adopted the principle of laying compensatory duties on the foreign article when imported. This we deem necessary to retain the home market, and not to discriminate against our own industry.
The income tax has been found very difficult to adjust so as to escape double taxation. But the committee thought it would be manifestly unjust to allow the large money operators and wealthy merchants, whose incomes might reach hundreds of thousands of dollars, to escape their due proportion of the burden. They hope they have succeeded in excluding from this tax the articles and subjects of gain and profit which are taxed in another form.
The committee have been greatly embarrassed by the Canadian
reciprocity treaty. They have been obliged to omit many
articles which, with a light tax, would have produced a
large revenue. This is but one of many illustrations of the
evil of commercial treaties, which are in direct violation
of the letter and spirit of the Constitution. The treaty
making power has no more right to regulate commerce than it
has to declare war and raise armies and navies.
Return to Speeches Index